Recent Posts

Join the #TalkingSpaces Twitter Discussions on Child-Friendly Public Spaces

Join the #TalkingSpaces Twitter Discussions on Child-Friendly Public Spaces

  The city of Accra, Ghana, like others around Africa, is expanding at a rapid pace. The pressure on the ground in the metropolis to make way for urban development translates into the cutting down age-old trees, and the taking over of play grounds, parks, waterways, and other essential community resources.  City authorities’ […]

For African cities, ‘tactical urbanism’ has its limits

For African cities, ‘tactical urbanism’ has its limits

It was a few years ago that the framework of tactical urbanism, a concept particularly promoted and popularized by U.S. planning design firm Street Plans Collaborative, gained traction, particularly in the United States and European contexts. The idea of tactical urbanism refers to locally led, […]

Money in a slum: the logic of small gains

Money in a slum: the logic of small gains

Dagna Rams is a doctoral candidate at the Department of Social and Political Science at the University of Lausanne, researching urban management and the politics and economies at the heart of the slum communities/informal settlements of Old Fadama and Agbogbloshie (Ghana).

On a research outing around one of Accra’s informal settlements, my friend Abdallah (a slum activist and former slum dweller) and I confronted a business that struck us as a particularly exemplary manifestation of the economies found in informal settlements.

The business, located in a two-storey concrete building, towers over a dense neighbourhood of self-made housing. Each floor is dedicated to a different part of the venture: public showers and toilets on the ground floor and a school on the top. According to a colourful banner picturing plump babies in university hats, the school’s name is Genius Academy.

The owner, who had previously been making a profit by meeting the sanitation needs of the neighbourhood, recently ventured into education. “The Academy is almost a charity,” he clarified. “We only charge children a feeding fee of four Ghana cedis [less than 1 US dollar] a day.” In a cash-strapped neighbourhood, a business that is able to provide two for the price of one – that is, education and nourishment – is undeniably in high demand: all the classrooms were full of pupils to the point of breaking.

The most straightforward business idea in an informal settlement is to act like a state, the big absentee in the place, and charge for it. Build a bridge and start charging for the crossing. Build toilets and start charging per visit. Establish a school and start charging per day.

But what Genius Academy does better than the state or private institutions outside the slums is to respond to the nature of the profits in the informal sector. People can afford some services as long as they are inexpensive and paid in small instalments,  rather than in big bulks. A person may be earning 20-30 Ghanaian cedis a day, but the money does not stay long in their pocket. After  5 cedis for food per family member, 1 cedi for the morning toilet, 2 cedis towards a weekly rent, 4 cedis for the child’s education, 2 cedis for transport, and so on, the budget crumbles. The ultimate gains are small and, on top of that, they come in small increments.

Density – having a great number of people living close to one another – is one of the aspects of the neighbourhood that fuels and sustains this economy of small and incremental gains. The entrepreneur behind Genius Academy recognizes that the main strategy for mitigating the small income generated from each pupil is to increase the number of pupils to the point of breaking the establishment. The classes are filled to the brink. And as only a small fee is demanded from each child, every child counts. I know a grassroots activist who established a scholarship programme in his squatter settlement only to be bullied later by a director of one of the settlement’s private educational establishment’s for “stealing business from him”.

In this context the high density of the neighbourhood, which translates into high demand for services, keeps the fees affordable in the absence of state or non-governmental subsidy. Paradoxically, high density might be a tool for profit-making and price lowering.

A similar logic of gain is also present in the businesses of the mothers whose children attend the Academy. Many work in the nearby markets selling tomatoes, onions and yams. Social anthropologist James Ferguson argues in his recent book Give a Man a Fish: Reflections on the New Politics of Distribution that commercial strategies characteristic of the urban poor are inherently distributive in their nature. Ferguson’s reflection finds its resonances in Accra. Walking through the open-air markets located next to informal settlements in Accra, one sees sellers sitting shoulder to shoulder and selling the same product from a limited stock.  Is this practice simple commerce? Or is this practice a form of distribution of potential gains between the sellers? It is also hard to imagine that the same market strategies would yield a similar profit outside a dense and central neighborhood, bustling with human commotion and a high number of potential customers.

In her article “The Bridge to Sodom and Gomorroah,” Yepoka Yeebo argues that slum communities such as Old Fadama, one of Accra’s biggest, are stepping stones in people’s lives. A similar tone of hope reverberates in The New York Times oft-cited article on India’s poster slum, Dharavi. It might be, the articles argue, that the men and women live in slums and suffer from poor sanitation, poor housing, and proximity to polluted environments, but the costs of living are lower than elsewhere, and therefore their situation lasts as long as it takes to secure a better life in a better part of town.

This narrative points to a long debate between two positions on slums: one that sees the bright side that casts the slum dwellers as calculative actors, who forgo safe lives to reap future benefits, and one that is less hopeful, envisioning slums as poverty traps. Rarer are narratives that depict hopes and traps as entwined.

Density is one of such double-edged swords. In the absence of jobs that allow decent gains, dense neighbourhoods seem to offer what sparser neighbourhoods lack: more jobs and lower costs. But, there is a paradox too, namely the density is both what allows gains in this context, but also what keeps these gains at a small level.

Small gains, money leaving pockets as quickly as it ends up in them, is an important barrier for social and geographic mobility. An informal settlement such as Old Fadama (or Dharavi) is always embedded in a larger urban milieu. It is not enough to ask whether a slum as a singular entity is a stepping stone to something better, one also has to ask whether the city in which the informal settlement is located can accommodate the transition from informal to formal housing.

Accra, where Old Fadama is located, posits a challenge in this regard. Aside from a few districts that avoid easy classifications, the majority of the city’s neighbourhoods are either densely inhabited by people earning lower incomes or sparse and often inhabited by people on foreign salaries. In other words, central districts that could accommodate urbanites graduating from slums are congested, and those that are not congested require harder currency. To make matters worse, almost everywhere in Accra renters have to pay an annual advance to rent a room. In comparison, in Old Fadama as well as in other informal communities, rent, similar to the school fees at the Genius Academy, is paid in smaller and more manageable chunks.

In the slum economies of Accra, density and small gains reinforce one another. High density allows profits in spite of low prices. The urban poor, who otherwise might lack in capital and be cut off from supply chains, are still able to make profits as the limited goods they can offer meet the high commotion of central and dense neighbourhoods.

One of the common misconceptions about slums that various slum activists work to dispel is that living in slums is cheap. Ayona Datta in her passionate book on Delhi’s squatter settlements, The Illegal City: Space, Law and Gender in a Delhi Squatter Settlement, reminds readers that slum-dwellers often cannot afford having diarrhoea, as each visit to a slum toilet costs money. But what slums and their small private entreprises such as the Genius Academy might be good at, at least compared to the rest of the city, is that they offer dwellers services and housing that respond to the ways in which they earn money. There is a word  in one Ghanaian language, Ga that conveys this reality: nokofio, “something small”. This word is used to signify the small and absurd gifts that trickle down to people from influence-seeking politicians, but it also stands for small gains from labour.

Foster’s World: Seeing Ga Mashie from Child Perspective

Foster’s World: Seeing Ga Mashie from Child Perspective

Foster Malm, 13, moves through one of Jamestown’s bustling markets with remarkable ease. Black iPhone covertly at the ready, he shoots off the hip, capturing unexpected market-goers moving through daily life. Although barely audible over the usual market place chatter, the camera shutter sounds off […]

African Urbanism Conversations / 001 / Agbogbloshie

African Urbanism Conversations / 001 / Agbogbloshie

In this first African Urbanism Conversation, participants discuss the urban development, social, political, economic and environmental context of Agbogbloshie and Old Fadama, often typified as “Africa’s largest e-waste dump.” The conversation provides local context for a better understanding of what’s happening in Agbogbloshie and Old Fadama, […]

“Making space for history” in Accra’s Ga Mashie neighborhood

“Making space for history” in Accra’s Ga Mashie neighborhood

Cultural tourism walks a precarious line. Private sector investments can generate significant socio-economic benefits for community members and revitalize cultural interests. On the other hand there are many opportunities for exploitation— interest groups stand to profit from over-development, pricing out existing low-income residents. As the growing number of arts, culture and touristic activities in Accra’s historical district Ga Mashie continue to yield intense attention, including private sector interests, it is clear that something needs to be done. On Saturday, October 24th, esteemed community leaders including Ga chiefs, royalty, government officials, scholars and activists gathered at the National Museum for the Bleema Noko (Days Gone By) Cultural Fundraising Event to address the current condition and future development of Brazil Lane, a vibrant side street that branches off of the main thoroughfare High Street in the Usshertown area of Ga Mashie.

According to the Brazil Heritage Foundation, who organized the fundraiser, private sector real estate developers and interest groups are impinging on Brazil Lane, which is anything but tablula rasa. Brazil House is the main cultural anchor on Brazil Lane but the street is saturated with tangible connections to the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade such as Franklin House, an old slave house built around 1750 constructed from the brick ballast of slave ships and its adjacent public square where slaves were once auctioned and sold. Brazil House and Brazil Lane trace their origins to seven families of Afro-Brazilian returnees who arrived in Usshertown between 1829 and 1836 and settled and integrated into the indigenous Otublohum Ga community. The story of these freed Brazilian slaves who arrived in Ghana from Bahia and came to be known as the Tabom (also written “Tabon”) is as pertinent to Accra’s cultural history as the diverse African diaspora that was displaced by slavery.

IMG_7682

IMG_9075
William Franklin House, a small slave fort turned communal dwelling place on Brazil Lane. Franklin House was used to keep slaves as part of Accra’s central role in the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade.

Progress should not expunge history—this is one major concern confronting the future of Ga Mashie development. Nonetheless, some development is necessary to restore historical integrity to Brazil Lane’s crumbling heritage sites. Franklin House, for instance, is a prime example of slave architecture from the 18th century colonial period but the structure is visibly deteriorating. Ussher Fort and James Fort, both UNESCO World Heritage Sites not far from Brazil Lane, have closed their doors to tourists and museum-goers and are beginning to succumb to urban blight.

The Foundation’s campaign aims to empower local residents to take control of development and restoration projects and capitalize on existing tourism potential, but it is important to remember that these structures are more than tourist attractions. Ussher Fort and James Fort held slaves before they were shipped across the Atlantic to the New World and later served as prisons until the end of the 20th century. Built by the British in the late 17th century, James Fort was the center of British colonial administration of the Gold Coast and served as a major outpost for slave trade until the mid 19th century. Ussher Fort, which currently houses the Monuments Division offices of the Ghana Museum and Monuments Board, once held Ghana’s first President Kwame Nkrumah, who was a central forefather in the fight for independence. Keeping these structures in good condition is imperative to preserving and enriching critical historical and cultural connections.

In the case of Brazil House, Ga, Tabom and Brazilian relations amalgamate in this two-story building. Brazil House was built on land granted to the original seven Tabom families by the Otublohum chief. It was restored thanks to significant support from Ghanaian and Brazilian private sectors, which was leveraged by the Brazilian Embassy following President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s 2005 visit to Brazil House. Once home to cultural events and a rich photographic collection of Tabom descendants, the museum on the ground floor of Brazil House constitutes the only commemorative structure to Ghana’s Tabom heritage. Today Brazil House bears few traces of its rich ancestry, save for the sign and plaque on the building’s front façade.

The museum is currently defunct—regarded as a no man’s land by tourists and locals alike. Without legitimized exhibition space, museum-worthy cultural artifacts vanish into private collections, like the ones displayed at Bleema Noko, and the Tabom are reduced to footnotes in the annals of history. This campaign, according to symposium speaker Nat Amarteifio, architectural historian and former Mayor of Accra, represents “an opportunity to reinstate the popular history of one of the most neglected, marginalized groups in our society.” Most academic studies focus on the Akan-Asante clashes with colonialists since those ethnic groups dominated political and economic relations at the time. Only within the past 60 years have scholars even begun to look into coastal society contributions outside of slave trade dynamics. But Accra and its peoples are more than products of colonialism and capitalism.

The Tabom rapidly and seamlessly assimilated into Ga society upon their arrival in 1829. Their heritage, such as a wealth of knowledge about artisanal craftsmanship, agricultural production, blacksmithing, carpentry, masonry, tailoring and irrigation techniques, sublimated into Ga society, making their legacies difficult to trace. Musicologists Dr. Juan Diego Diaz and Benjamin Amakye Boateng (University of Ghana, Music Department), both presenters at the Bleema Noko symposium, point out that a distinct Tabom identity is preserved in arpa music, a style of percussion-based music that blends African and Brazilian influences. Arpa is just one of many Afro-Brazilian manifestations. In this thread practicing arpa simultaneously connects and distinguishes the Tabom from other Afro-Brazilian musical genres such as maracatu, capoeira and afoxé. However, these cultural expressions need a place in contemporary society—public, accessible platforms like performance spaces or museum exhibitions— if they are to be celebrated as living culture rather than as bygone relics.

The built environment may be the Rosetta Stone in untangling this understated legacy. The Tabom were instrumental in shaping Accra—their influence is codified in present day Jamestown structures. Many of the wells common in Jamestown compounds were dug by Tabom workers to deliver potable water to factories. In addition, the Tabom were at the vanguard of stone architecture building practices, which had been previously only used for colonial castles and forts. Their arrival and influence marked a departure from mud-thatched huts and the beginning of modern architecture in Accra. Amarteifio insists that these structures should be regarded as World Heritage Sites, let alone National Heritage Sites, to commemorate and preserve a dematerializing legacy, stating, “We do what we are doing so that [the Tabom] do not disappear.”

This is not Ga Mashie’s first “cultural revitalization” proposal.  Ophelia Akiwumi, philanthropist at the Brazil Ghana Heritage Foundation, expressed the hope of transforming Jamestown into a cultural Mecca uniting artists, musicians, craftsmen and the African diaspora in a way that leverages Brazil Lane’s cultural heritage to benefit and uplift current residents. But thanks to previous coordinated endeavors, Ga Mashie already welcomes thousands of visitors who come to participate in walking tours, traditional celebrations and popular events like the Chale Wote Street Art Festival. Mona Boyd, CEO of the tourism company Landtours, added that she believes Usshertown will have the support of the tourism industry, however landmarks like Brazil House, Ussher Fort and Jamestown Lighthouse already compel tourists to wander the winding streets amidst the hustle and bustle of Accra’s oldest and most densely populated neighborhood, so does Ga Mashie really need another cultural tourism initiative?

The ideas presented at Bleema Noko are not radical. The intervention aims to build space for a community and a foundation or coalition of community leaders can promote development that does not compromise the culture, tradition or livelihoods of current residents. None of the goals presented at Bleema Noko are ostensibly controversial—who is going to argue against investing in the local economy, historical preservation, cultural celebrations or a better quality of life for others? A better question might be who is going to help make that happen?

The Brazil Ghana Heritage Foundation is looking for an answer. Boyd called on community leaders to embrace these development efforts. Brazilian Ambassador Irene Vida Gala stressed the importance of local coordination not just to protect local interests, but also to act as a substrate for developing partnerships with private companies. She reiterated the urgency of the situation stating that now is the time not to solicit money, but rather to present ideas, petition the government to create policies that invest in culture, and reach out to established networks for support. The Brazilian companies on the ground in Ghana ultimately cannot contribute without local involvement and oversight, said Gala.

While the lack of financial resources is an impediment, it is not the root of the problem, but rather a symptom of a more profound breakdown of community values.  In the case of the Brazil House Museum, the poor condition signals disintegrating respect for past connections and divestment in potential. “It [Brazil House] does not represent the Tabom people and does not represent the relations between Brazil and Africa—Brazil-Ghana in particular,” Gala declared. She implored Ghana reflect on how it values land and property before it invests in heritage. The Tabom are part of a larger, transnational moment in history, repatriating the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade narrative. Discerning their contributions legitimizes Tabom agency and adds another dimension to the African diaspora. But if stakeholders (businesses, community members, public institutions etc.) do not place high worth on historical resources and public spaces, cultural tourism initiatives will collapse.

Successfully sustained cultural spaces are not end goals—they are comprehensive processes that require institutional and infrastructural support. As an investment in the future of Ga Mashie and Accra, the success of the Brazil Lane initiative should not be incentivized by financial gain, but by pride for Tabom heritage and lively public spaces. This symposium is the first of many discussions articulating cultural ownership and placemaking. Whichever way the talks develop, whether or not Brazil Lane will become a springboard for other revitalization projects, one clear challenge moving forward will be coordinating efforts across the board. Although various politics implicated in Brazil House complicate restoration projects, both developers and community members need to be at the table to arrive at a time when Brazil House open its doors to the world again.

Re-imagining Accra’s “public spaces”

Re-imagining Accra’s “public spaces”

What if we let go of the limiting idea of our public spaces as “city parks” and began exploring the entire range of social spaces that already exist in the city? This is the first in a series of posts.  Talented architects, designers and public […]

Accra: Sensing the City Through Sound

Accra: Sensing the City Through Sound

In May, African Urbanism contributed to MIT’s Community Innovation Lab (CoLab Radio) “Listening to the City” series. The series includes sounds from cities such as a market in Mexico City, a struggling street market in Thessaloniki, Greece, and sounds of Los Angeles’ street economy. What do […]


My Diary

Post ID:

 

The city of Accra, Ghana, like others around Africa, is expanding at a rapid pace. The pressure on the ground in the metropolis to make way for urban development translates into the cutting down age-old trees, and the taking over of play grounds, parks, waterways, and other essential community resources.  City authorities’ plans and the competing, uncoordinated priorities of city dwellers, vendors, commercial vehicles, private developers and others contribute to traffic jams and congestion, infrastructure and services challenges, excluding recreational public spaces from the development narrative and ignoring their importance in the shaping of sustainable cities.

Join Mmofra Foundation, Foundation for Contemporary Art – Ghana, and African Urbanism in two upcoming twitter chats themed #TALKINGSPACES to discuss the importance of our public spaces and with the focus on children and youth.

“Child-friendly public spaces”
Tuesday, November 7,2017
4:00 pm to 5:30 pm GMT

Q1. How do we understand public spaces in Ghana? In Africa? #talkingspaces
Q2. What role does public space play in our country? What’s our relationship with space/public space? #talkingspaces
Q3. Why are our parks neglected in urban development? #talkingspaces
Q4. What are the success stories of vibrant public spaces that we can learn from? #talkingspaces
Q5. How can our public spaces help address Accra (and other cities’) urban challenges? #talkingspaces
Q6. What can we (citizens, artists, planners, architects, govt, etc.) do to make our public spaces more child friendly? #talkingspaces

“Parks”
Tuesday, November 14, 2017
4:00pm to 5:30pm GMT

We want to hear from you. Join our twitter chat, share your ideas, and contribute to a wider conversation on improving our public spaces for the next generation!

This series is part of a larger public spaces engagement by Mmofra Foundation under the Creating Great Public Spaces in Three African Cities Project, supported through Healthbridge Canada and UN-Habitat.